Strawberry Cheesecake Ice Cream

Jump to Recipe Print Recipe

There’s something about homemade Strawberry Cheesecake Ice Cream that just feels like the summer you always wanted. Maybe it’s the swirl of roasted berries that bleeds into creamy custard, the crunch of graham cracker, or that familiar scent—sweet, fruity, and just a touch tangy—when you crack open the container after it’s been chilling overnight. This isn’t just a scoop from the grocery store. It’s the flavor of strawberries roasted until jammy, mixed with cheesecake richness and those nostalgic hits of buttery, crumbly cookie. Every summer, I wait for berries to get their act together at the farmer’s market before making a batch of this ice cream—and when those gems hit their stride, there’s no turning back.

If you’ve only ever had basic strawberry ice cream, you’re in for a total glow-up with this version. There’s a custard base that’s extra silky, thanks to a combo of cream cheese and egg yolks, and a strawberry purée made sharp and vibrant with a touch of lemon. The best part? Those swirls of graham cracker woven through every scoop—you find yourself digging around with your spoon, hunting for that little crunch in the creamy pink. This is the kind of dessert you want to eat quietly, just enjoying every chilly, tangy, sweet-smelling spoonful, but honestly, it becomes the thing people won’t stop talking about at a backyard dinner.

Table of Contents

When Strawberry Cheesecake Ice Cream Becomes Centrepiece

Some desserts just refuse to fade into the background—and that’s exactly what happens when strawberry cheesecake ice cream is on the table. It’s bright and playful next to anything chocolate, but wrapped in enough nostalgia to make even your most dessert-skeptical aunt go back for seconds. This is the ice cream you break out when it’s too hot for real cheesecake, or when a homemade treat is the only answer to a long, sticky afternoon. One summer, I brought a tub layered with extra graham cracker to a 4th of July picnic. Nobody touched the pie, but the ice cream disappeared so fast you’d think it had never existed. The contrast of cold, creamy cheesecake tang with the almost-candied roasted strawberries—yeah, it’s the stuff people remember.

The Ingredients That Define This Cheesecake Ice Cream

This ice cream is all about layers of flavor, each one balancing richness, tang, and outright summer sweetness. Here’s what makes it work:

Strawberries – the star, roasted to dial up fruitiness and deepen the flavor until it borders on candy.
Granulated sugar – brings out the juiciness in roasted berries and smooths out the base without overpowering.
Lemon juice – that secret pop of acidity to keep the strawberries lively and cut through the cream.
Whole milk – gives the custard its backbone, keeping things light enough to scoop straight from the freezer.
Cream cheese – pushes the “cheesecake” angle, bringing classic tang and a luscious mouthfeel that lasts.
Light corn syrup – a little trick for extra scoopable, glossy ice cream with no icy bits.
Egg yolks – the velvet-maker, thickening and providing that luxurious custard texture.
Fine salt – just enough to sharpen the distinction between sweet and tart.
Pure vanilla extract – a quiet layer of warmth and aroma under all that fruit and cream.
Heavy cream – the rich finisher; together with the milk, it makes for seriously luscious ice cream.
Graham cracker sheets – crushed into chunky swirls for those bites of buttery crunch and classic cheesecake nostalgia.

See the recipe card below for the full list of ingredients and measurements.

Building Flavor Layer by Layer

Everything about this strawberry cheesecake ice cream comes back to coaxing flavor from every ingredient, one step at a time. First, roasting the strawberries. This simple move pulls out every drop of sweetness and concentrates the essence of the fruit. Toss the halved berries with sugar and a quick drizzle of lemon, then slide them into a hot oven. As they roast, you can actually smell the kitchen change—sweet, a little floral, but with a jammy note that comes out only when the fruit goes just past soft.

While those berries cool and soak in their own syrup, you turn your attention to the custard base. The combination of whole milk and cream cheese (trust me, don’t skip the softening!) melts down on the stove, while egg yolks are whisked with just enough sugar to go pale and ribbon-y. Slowly temper those yolks with the warm milk mixture, so you get all the richness and none of the scramble. It’s an active process—no walking away—stirring over the heat until, suddenly, the custard thickens, clinging to the back of a spoon in that telltale silky line.

Once the cream, salt, and vanilla are whisked in, everything gets strained for the smoothest result (especially if, say, you’re sometimes too eager with the heat). This is where patience kicks in: the whole base needs to chill properly before you even think about churning. But it’s worth it. The cold thickens everything; flavors settle and step forward.

After pouring in the berry purée, now vivid pink, it all goes into your ice cream maker. There’s a rhythm to this part—the slow churn as it transforms from liquid to nearly-soft-serve, that moment you swipe a spoon along the paddle and get the very first taste.

From Simmer to Scoop: Every Step Matters

Start by roasting your strawberries. Lay them out on a lined tray, sprinkle with sugar, and drizzle with lemon juice—toss gently and give them some room. After 30 to 35 minutes in the oven, they should turn deeply fragrant and syrupy, with a color that shifts from innocent red to a rich, jewel-toned pink.
While your berries cool, blend them into a silky purée. Stash this in the fridge to get cold—it’s easier to swirl into your custard later when everything’s at the same temperature.
Next up, start the custard. In a saucepan, mesh together whole milk, softened cream cheese, and corn syrup, whisking until totally smooth but stopping just before it boils. The scent’s subtle here—creamy and a bit tangy if you lean in.
Whip up the egg yolks and sugar in a separate bowl until the mixture drips off the whisk in thick ribbons. Now, temper the eggs—drizzle in a little warm milk, whisking all the while. This keeps the yolks velvety, not scrambled.
Pour everything back into the pot and cook, stirring constantly over medium heat. Don’t get distracted. In about 5-7 minutes, the custard will thicken enough to coat a spoon, and you’ll feel the texture change from thin to rich.
Turn off the heat, stir in the salt, vanilla, and heavy cream. Strain this golden mixture through a fine sieve to catch any rogue bits, then stash it in the fridge for several hours (overnight is best) so the flavors meld and the base gets cold.
Once the custard chills, whisk in your strawberry purée. Get ready for the burst of color and the aroma that says “ice cream shop,” only better.
Churn the mixture in your ice cream maker until it’s thickened and fluffing up—usually about 20–25 minutes. When it’s barely soft-serve, layer it into your container, sprinkling crushed graham crackers as you go. Each scoop gets a hint of crunch and nostalgia.
Lay plastic wrap or parchment right on top before sealing with the lid, then freeze until gloriously firm. It takes willpower, but the wait is worthwhile.

Texture, Flavor, and That First Bite

When you finally grab a spoon, break through the frosty surface, and take a bite—it’s the meeting of all those sitting-on-the-porch summer dreams. The base is creamy but not leaden; there’s a faint tang from the cream cheese and the most satisfying, smooth mouthfeel you only get from proper custard. Every now and then you hit a swirl of roasted strawberry, concentrated and bright, almost like a ripple of summer jam. Then comes the graham cracker: buttery, ever-so-slightly spiced, crackling quietly in the ice cream’s chill. The flavor keeps shifting as you eat—sometimes you get a mouthful of berries, other times the cheesecake dairy richness is dominant. But each spoonful is balanced, bold, and never too sweet. A little bit like your favorite diner cheesecake thrown into a snowstorm.

Little Details That Make a Big Difference

It’s the little things that keep strawberry cheesecake ice cream from good to “oh, wow.” For one, don’t skip roasting the berries—fresh is fine, but roasted? That’s where the depth comes from. The corn syrup keeps the base impossibly creamy, but if you’re strict about it, swap in a little honey or golden syrup—just know the texture might shift toward softer.

If you don’t have graham crackers, crushed digestive biscuits will do in a pinch, adding that nutty, almost toasty undertone. Want to go wild? A swirl of lemon curd between layers instead of crackers gives you a sharp, zesty twist that pairs beautifully with the richness. Just avoid piling in too many mix-ins during churning; chunky bits can drag the mixture down and mess with the silky scoop.

When you’re storing leftovers (if that ever happens), press plastic directly to the surface before freezing to keep pesky ice crystals away. Homemade ice cream can sometimes get too firm, so leave your tub out for a few minutes on the counter before scooping for the creamiest texture.

Serving Ideas That Turn Ice Cream Into an Event

This strawberry cheesecake ice cream doesn’t need much dressing up, but if you want to turn an average Thursday night into the stuff of memory, try serving big scoops with sliced fresh berries on top, maybe a few more crumbs of graham scattered like confetti. If you’re feeling ambitious (or just bracing for a crowd), sandwich a thick layer between homemade sugar cookies for the ultimate freezer treat.

Sometimes, on particularly warm evenings, I even serve a scoop alongside a square of angel food cake or tuck it into waffle cones for a nostalgic touch. For a grown-up twist, a drizzle of balsamic reduction or a dusting of flaky sea salt brings out extraordinary complexity. Whether it’s piled up at a summer party or eaten straight from the tub under the soft light of the open fridge, there’s no wrong way to savor this.

FAQs about Strawberry Cheesecake Ice Cream

Can I make strawberry cheesecake ice cream without an ice cream maker?

Yes—you can use a no-churn method, but the results will be slightly less creamy and airy. Pour your mixed custard and strawberry base into a container, freeze, and stir every hour or so until firm. The texture won’t be quite as smooth, but it’ll still be delicious.

What’s the best way to store homemade strawberry cheesecake ice cream?

Keep your ice cream in a freezer-safe, airtight container. For bonus freshness, press plastic wrap or parchment right up against the surface to keep it from getting icy. It’s best enjoyed within a couple of weeks for top flavor and texture.

Can I substitute frozen berries if fresh aren’t available?

Absolutely—frozen berries will work just fine, especially once roasted. Let them thaw and drain well first; this helps keep the mixture from turning watery. Roasting still coaxes out concentrated flavor from even the off-season berries.

How do I get the perfect swirl of graham cracker in my strawberry cheesecake ice cream?

Layer the crushed graham cracker between scoops of churned ice cream as you transfer it to your container. Don’t mix it in during churning, or it will dissolve. The layering technique keeps those bits distinct and crunchy in every scoop.

The beauty of strawberry cheesecake ice cream is that every spoonful feels like its own small celebration—creamy, tangy, sweet, just the right hint of crunch. Whether you serve it up on a sun-blasted patio, as a birthday surprise, or curled up indoors with a bowl all to yourself, it never fails to brighten the moment. Next time the berries are calling your name, let this recipe do them real justice—you might just find it’s your new, impossible-to-beat summer tradition.

More Delicious Recipes

Cranberry and Orange Muffins: These muffins bring a fruity twist that’s perfect for summer gatherings, similar to the flavors in your strawberry cheesecake ice cream.
Peanut Butter Frozen Yogurt Bars: A cool and creamy dessert, these bars combine sweet and tangy notes, ideal for refreshing summer treats.
Butter Pecan Ice Cream: Like strawberry cheesecake ice cream, this recipe features creamy textures and rich flavors, making it a delightful choice for ice cream lovers.

Benchi